I haven’t seen a pattern as to when or why this should happen. Hi thanks the pictures are great and I would guess I am at the lower end of this but I was hoping the scales actually can do it more accurately? Someone at Garmin has made a very deliberate decision to be anti-competitive here and disable various functions that the developers have probably had to comment out. Can you get feedback from Garmin why they have a broken integration? They did an RMA and I returned the unit, 2 weeks later I got a replacement new unit. I’m sort of annoyed at the inability to store multiple readings a day, so I started having a look at the JSON that Garmin Connect supplies to the browser in the background. So people are allowed to fester until they can make time to call Garmin during a work day. Either way – there’s really no excuse for Garmin not offering 3rd parties the weight data (nor any ability for you to export it out yourself). I’ve had Garmins since 2002, but for some reason, this has vexed me. PCMag Digital Group. I’d push back on that from Garmin AU Support to be honest. The article also raises another question. The whole reason I got the scale was for accurate FTP VO2 and other measurements on my Edge but at the moment it still has the weight that I manually entered. in your opinion is new updated model on the way? Not a lot of positivity out there for this product. I now have my scales in my dining room, which is sub optimal, but at least they connect. So my question was asked in 2005 in the first pass review of the Garmin scale so hoping something has changed: Is there some way for me to get the Tanita BC 1000 data into Garmin Connect? One of the major reason I picked the Garmin over the others was the ability to have the scale update my account consistently in the morning and then use the scale through the day (before / after an exercise) to see water weight, etc. It simply plots your weight against various time frames that you can adjust (7 days, 4 weeks, 6 months, 12 months). You mentionned that “in order to be a user on the scale, you must have an account on Garmin Connect”. Well my scales recognised me and sent all data to Garmin connect. Have you had any issues with it being extremely sensitive turning on? I did so at a granular level – even logging vitamins – I have a fitness tracker for the daily and I use an Edge for all my cycling. Anyone know? As Fenix users, we were able to setup the scale practically without reading the instructions! Here’s how: I’ve seen in the past is that while these metrics may not be absolutely accurate, November I wrote about all of the WiFi scale options on the market, click here to Subscribe without commenting. Keep it up! When it went on sale again for the new year, I caved and bought from the amazon link. So I guess that the “high” setting should only be used for professional athlete’s . now stuck on the wrench after setting up wifi, Connect on phone and Garmin express bith say setup complete . Select Settings If you bought the scale, they got your money and ran. It shows all those numbers on its screen (something a lot of smart scales hide), and automatically sends the information to an app. Scale attaching via bluetooth but the App can then not remember the details of the scale. I swim, bike and run. Initial setup and syncing didn't go smoothly in my testing, although the data did reliably show up in the app once the kinks ironed themselves out. MFP will have updated your weight next time you log in.”. I note you can connect mfp and strava in the garmin connect app, so am hoping the scale will match up with mfp? Got a spread of 3.4 kg between them. In fact, they likely added code to keep that from happening automatically. Over the years I have found their new products work about 1 in every 3. I’ve just tried the scales and they’re working as normal again. My brother out in nyc who is very tech savvy hasnt either been able to sync data. I got an Index Scale about a month ago. With the Garmin Index Smart Scale you can register your weight, body fat, muscle mass, etc., and automatically synchronize it to the Garmin Connect app via your WiFi connection. I like to exercise and track my progress, but I am by no means a hard core trainer/athlete. Garmin Support think this is all as should be. link to forums.garmin.com. Currently I haven’t been able to link the scale to anything since I have not been able to link the scale to my router (they put in a ticket to the engineers and I am now waiting). I know you said the index won’t share its data to training peaks and other apps, do you know if it will share to my fitness pal? You’ll also notice two buttons/sliders right near it. , Ray is totally spot on. Is there any magic to get it to pull updates? I still have the same scale I’ve been using for years. I changed it back to activity class 7 and now I can use the scale again – please warn users that the scale is not usable or accurate if set above activity level 7. THUMBS UP IF YOU LIKE THIS VIDEO SUBSCRIBE NOW / Drop a comment below I hope you enjoyed this review of the Garmin Index Smart Scale! FWIW, the upgrade to 2.7 happened over wifi seamlessly, and all set up was done via mobile connect app… really hapy with the scales… Since 3 days ago it shows me constantly 7% (also, sudden gain of 0,4 kg in bone mass, I got a new extra bone, I suppose….). Post-ride weight was 6 lbs less than pre-ride (all water, right? At the low end of the price spectrum are the Nuyu Wireless Scale and Pivotal Living scale ($39; review pending). The app doesn't advise you on how to change your weight or even tell you whether it's within a range that would be considered healthy—although not everyone wants that kind of generalized advice from a fitness app. They’re just as easy to use and provide the same base weight data. But at the end of the day, you might just be wondering “What does Ray use when not testing new products?”. I have set it up on my iphone Garmin app and now my husband trying to add to his. Use Backcountry.com or Competitive Cyclist with either the coupon code DCRAINMAKER for first time users saving 15% on applicable products. Not sure what you mean. Love your site, and have been using it for year. As do not know whether to hold off purchasing the 1st version or not. JM. Any ideas if Garmin is going to come out with a new scale? Straight-up, full-flippin’ stop. Of all the best smart scales, the Wyze Scale is our top budget pick because it's loaded with features and costs a mere $20. However, if you don’t care about advanced metrics and you use other platforms for your weight – then you can save a bunch of money and get a Withings or Fitbit scale. Please investigate and add the below information to your review (to warn other unsuspecting users…). Thank you! I think you misinterpreted Ray’s original comments. This time I had to re-configure my WiFi setting in the app but I ended up in the same situation: “Network Connection Error” and a persistent wrench display on the scale. I’m in 15% at best, probably more like 18-20%. Now, the Garmin Index scale is not without its oddities. At least my bone mass is staying constant! What is they key to getting the other person to show up on the scale as person Number 2 after he accepts my invite? Well yesterday – I received my scale form Amazon (after a lot of research) and have it all hooked up and running. exactly the same problem here. Utter garbage product. I will ship it back and get refunded within the next days. However, if you didn’t want to track that secondary weigh in you wouldn’t need to do anything, just let the scale deposit it into wifi/Garmin Connect land. Lot’s of people with the same problem. the Index or the Portal ist not passing the accutal weight to my watch. Why? The connections to Garmin, Fitbit, and Strava are API based. Software update. Most importantly: Is the scale worth the premium over others on the market? I bought mine in January 2017. Any rumors on a new scale coming out in the near future? Cracking open the box you’ll find the scale wrapped in a protective sleeve. It’s a shame, because when they work as they should they’re great and I really like them. The first and default chart is your weight chart. An 11 minute response time!!! This allows their Garmin Connect accounts to tie into the scale. B. Footing the bill to integrate to other companies’ websites cost more than the revenue generated by extra scales sold? They can even hide the weight from appearing on the scale at all, so that they can track it for their healthcare team without ever looking at the numbers. I wouldn’t recommend this to anyone currently. Lastly on the site you can add a ‘Goal’ metric, which simply shows up as a black line on all your graphs. In Garmin Connect mobile I go into settings > user settings, tap weight. I have not consistently got it to work but some tools I used to use went away. More so after a scale update many of us on the garmin forum have innaccurate body fat readings. My Verizon router and the scale do not appear to like each other. 2. Free NEXT DAY shipping on select items. 2) the Withings > Training Peaks transfer also seems borked these days. But since it sounds like you have such a capability, I’d ask why you’d have bought the scale then – since you knew it would break on this day in the future? Thank you. I have contacted Garmin support but didn’t get a very meaningful answer. Hi Ray In the mobile app I can see the weight measurements. I would think a very simple CSV export of date/weight metrics would be perfect. For the past 4 years I have struggled to get below 215 – calories in vs calories out is not always the formula. Bizarrely although there’s no problem with other Garmin products the Index fails to sync from Garmin Connect to MFP. Put my eight year old on – he gets 6.0%. But then why would Garmin add multi weigh-ins if they are discontinuing this product line. They only integrate with a limited number of devices, and their apps aren't great. Lastly, in that other comparison post I do talk to some of the more creative ways to get a 3rd party scale’s data (like Fitbit and Withings) into Garmin Connect. I guess, in this sense, my aging Withings scale actually works better than the Garmin one as it never fails to sync with MFP and will update my Garmin devices as often as I weigh in and sync them. It can handle weight up to 400 pounds, and is accurate to 0.1-pound. Super disappointed in Garmin. I have been a long time Garmin supporter, nearly 20 years, and with the issue I have had (and continue to have) with the Edge 1000 and now this – I’m done supporting them! Garmin's app doesn't have any special features for securely sharing your data with a healthcare team. Why are scales the only device that require a PhD in programming to set up via wifi? Any idea what happened to the update that is supposed to add the ability to take multiple readings per day? Just put the Ant+ adapter in the box if you are going to require it for set up. Yet still, three months after release – nothing has changed there. with me – and doesn’t require me to share it on some 3rd-party server somewhere. I was frustrated. I think this product was an experiment, a failed experiment, made by Garmin with customer’s money. I feel that they are stuck between a rock and a hard place. For 2 months since I bought the scale I was at 11.5-12.5% body fat. I have quite a few wifi products where I have spoken to manufacturers about the hardware, but when I look on their forums it’s always a settings issue. The Index is sturdy, but heavy for a bathroom scale at 6.2 pounds. It’s beyond crazy that I was scared of getting on the scale and ruining my daily morning wake up data point even if I wanted to weigh myself before and after a run etc. Select MyFitnessPal Has anyone else been having these issues? The challenge is that not everyone is like you or I (data focused & multi-platform). So, both of those things happily stick to the scale, and since the glass sits atop the black coloring, it’s crazy visible. The lack of data syncing to Training Peaks is a killer for me. It’s been popular amongst TrainerRoad users: link to forum.trainerroad.com. Which makes no sense whatsoever. Mine just started doing this. Now that it supports multiple weigh-ins a day, I am inclined to buy… grab one quickly now, while you still can, or wait for the very hypothetical (?) THAT SAID. BTW this isn’t isnt attack at you whatsoever. However I am currently a bit chubby with just a few hours of exercise in the last few months… plus it’s a good 5% below my Tanita scales… so don’t believe it. however the scales arrived today, and have set up first time, no problem, with additional users added easily, and all uploaded to the respective GC accounts within a minute or so…. Only recently the site and app have changed to add a time field when entering your weight. Hey, my weight page on Garmin Connect mobile app looks different from the one you have shown and I can’t find the options to add BMI records etc. As a side note- I’m also able to go for fitness assessments through the Army and get measured in a Bod-Pod, so it would be interesting to compare results.So why not just go to the Bod-Pod? It seems only weight is registered. At the time of writing I’ve been using it for over a year now, in this Garmin Index Smart Scale review you will find my experience with the scale. My Scale was working fine but for the last two weeks doesn’t seem able to upload at all – despite me setting it up from scratch again. Yes, I’m already a Garmin customer and use Garmin Connect, but they’re discouraging me from buying more of their hardware (i.e. I am sending my scale back and getting a Withings Scale instead. Just open up your router for a moment, let it connect, find the MAC address in your router then white-list it and lock your router back down. Unfortunately there is a bug in Myfitnesspal/Garmin where if you manually update the weight in myfitnesspal it will override the weight data from Garmin and kill the rest of the data in garmin connect. I personaly step on the scale when I get out of bed in the mornings. post long run weight data somewhere else anyway. I´m having some troubles trying to do that!